Big Picture
Roger Marshall spent two years as one of the faces of Make America Healthy Again (aka MAHA) in the Senate, chairing the MAHA Caucus built around Health Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr.’s agenda.
On Tuesday night, he lost his Kansas seat to Democrat Adam Hamilton, becoming the first Republican in nearly a century to lose a Senate race in the state. In Iowa, Zach Lahn, the gubernatorial candidate whose race Kennedy had called “the most important election going on in this country,” conceded to Democrat Rob Sand. By Wednesday morning, Democrats had taken control of both the U.S. House and the U.S. Senate.
The MAHA movement’s best-known voices had little to say about it. For two years, MAHA’s allies sold the movement to Republicans as a decisive voting bloc, backed by a $100 million fundraising campaign and claims that MAHA voters could make up roughly a tenth of the electorate. On Tuesday, that bloc could not save the candidates who embraced it most closely.
A closer look at the movement’s most visible figures helps explain why the promise rang hollow. For many of them, MAHA was never only a cause; it was also a revenue stream.
When the two pulled in different directions, the revenue usually won, and their audiences were rarely told. Only one of the two was on the ballot.
The (Broken) Political Promise
“The midterms are existential for the MAHA movement,” Tony Lyons, president of MAHA PAC, said in March as the super PAC launched a $100 million fundraising campaign to support Trump-endorsed MAHA candidates.
The PAC said the money would fund targeted campaigns, voter outreach and grassroots mobilization.
The pitch had been building for months. In August 2025, Lyons, then leading the advocacy group MAHA Action, promised to “bring out every last MAHA mom, every health-conscious voter, everyone in America who is sick of being lied to by Big Pharma, Big Food and Big Ag.” This February, a MAHA Action memo to Republican campaign leaders warned that the party was “renting MAHA voters” and had not yet won them over.
The money did not follow.
By April, MAHA PAC and its only aligned super PAC had about $412,000 in cash left after a few dozen donations, roughly half of them from entities tied to the drug industry, Politico reported. In late October, the Wall Street Journal reported that allied MAHA super PACs and nonprofits had spent roughly $4 million on candidates since January 2025, “far less than the $100 million promised,” and that most of the donors who had backed Kennedy in the last cycle were “missing in the midterms.”
Neither, by and large, did the movement’s biggest personalities.
The results were a rout. Early exit polls put President Trump’s approval at 38 percent, on pace for a record low for a president in a midterm, and analysts pointed first to the economy, the Iran war and the president himself. Health policy was not the headline of the night, but MAHA’s candidates went down with the rest. STAT News called the outcome “a potentially fatal blow“ to Kennedy’s movement.
MAHA’s candidates had to win. Its leaders did not.
The Test MAHA Set
MAHA’s central promise is transparency. Its leaders built their followings by telling audiences what industry wouldn’t: who funds the studies, what’s really in the product, who profits from the advice.
It turns out that “Follow the money” is less a slogan than the movement’s method.
Below, this article applies that method to the movement’s own leaders by asking three questions:
Where do their products come from?
Who pays them?
What do they sell?
In each case, it asks whether their audience was told.
Two patterns emerge:
Sometimes the money wins outright, and the cause gives way.
More often, the cause and the business are built to be inseparable, and the financial stake is simply left out.
Neither pattern depends on winning an election.
Test 1 - Where do MAHA leaders’ products come from?
In August, President Trump announced on Truth Social that up to 300,000 metric tons of beef could enter the United States without tariffs over the next 90 days, a bid to bring down grocery prices that had risen nearly 10 percent in a year. Pushback from his own coalition came quickly.
Alex Clark, one of the most-followed voices in the MAHA movement, asked publicly why the “America First” answer to expensive beef was more foreign beef.
Vani Hari said nothing. Her silence stood out. Hari, known to millions as “the Food Babe,” had just quote-posted the White House in support of American farmers and ranchers.
Hari made her name pressuring food companies to come clean about what was in their products, and she has since become a fixture at Department of Health and Human Services events. Truvani, the company she co-founded, sells that credibility, marketing its products as clean and honest alternatives to an opaque food industry.
However, the supply chain behind the brand tells a more global story.
Truvani’s flagship Grass Fed Collagen Peptides are sourced from Argentine cattle, and its Organic Monk Fruit comes from China. Sourcing ingredients abroad is common and legal. The issue is the gap between the brand’s America-first posture and its practice, and what that gap may have meant when an America-first policy fight landed on Hari’s own product category.
Truvani’s commitment to disclosure has limits of its own. A company built on calling out industry opacity keeps a “test results“ page that shows a single lead test with no date and no laboratory named.
Before the beef fight, ranchers got a social media post from Hari. During it, they got silence. Hari’s support for American ranchers lasted one post. Her collagen never stopped coming from Argentina.
And on Tuesday, as MAHA’s candidates lost, the collagen was still for sale.
Test 2 - Who pays these MAHA leaders?
Clark has built a large following as a voice of skepticism toward the pharmaceutical and agricultural industries, much of it through Culture Apothecary, a show that presents her as an independent voice in the wellness world.
Turning Point USA’s tax filings tell a different story.
The conservative group’s Form 990 lists Alexandra Clark as a “Contributor” and reports that it paid her $210,377 in the fiscal year that ended in June 2025, up from $120,393 three years earlier. According to a Turning Point press release, Turning Point also owns the Culture Apothecary brand.
Clark’s affiliation with Turning Point is no secret, and she has spoken about it. The question is what her audience understands. Another interesting connection, most likely not understood by her audience, is her connection to a pharmaceutical company called The Wellness Company. The outwardly anti-pharmaceutical podcaster has an active brand affiliation with the company, using her face to market their medical kit that includes amoxicillin. At a recent closed door MAHA Summit, speakers weighed the incentives for practitioners to overprescribe antibiotics like amoxicillin.
The issue isn’t her views. It’s whether her audience knows who is behind the platform delivering them. And unlike the candidates MAHA promised to elect, her salary was never up to the voters.
Test 3 - What products do they sell?
Kelly Ryerson, who posts as “Glyphosate Girl,” is among the country’s most prominent activists against the herbicide glyphosate.
According to a press release from 2022, she was named to the Global Advisory Board of Contact Organics, a company that sells glyphosate-free weed control products. The role does not appear in her biographies, social media profiles or disclosure statements.
For Ryerson, the cause and the business point the same way, and that is the problem. Every warning about glyphosate is also, in effect, a sales pitch for its replacement. Her audience isn’t told that a company she advises sells that replacement.
Zen Honeycutt built Moms Across America into one of the most visible anti-glyphosate groups in the country. The organization ran a storefront selling ION* Gut Support at $72 a bottle under its own promo code, MOMS15, marketed as able to repair “gut damage caused by glyphosate.”
The pattern is the same: the group warns about the damage, then sells the fix.
No election result changes that business. If anything, a movement that has lost its leverage in Washington has more reason to keep its audience afraid.
The Business Model
The reason MAHA’s leaders came through Tuesday unscathed is structural.
Their income is built on affiliate codes, private-label supplements, sponsorships, salaries and advisory roles. None of it depends on winning a seat in Congress, and all of it depends on keeping an audience engaged.
The economics are simple, and they explain why Tuesday’s losses barely touched the movement’s leaders. A wellness influencer’s audience is the asset. Trust is what turns that audience into revenue, and there are several ways to collect it.
The most common is the affiliate code: a discount like MOMS15 that tracks each sale back to the person who promoted it and pays them a share. A step up is the private-label product. Instead of earning a cut of someone else’s supplement, the influencer puts their own name on one, as Hari has with Truvani, and keeps the margin. Then there are the arrangements audiences rarely see: sponsorships, salaried roles with organizations that own the platform, and advisory board seats with companies whose products line up with the influencer’s message.
What these have in common is that they reward attention, not outcomes. A campaign has to win. A supplement only has to sell, and fear sells well.
That’s also why disclosure matters more here than in ordinary advertising. A follower who trusts an influencer because she seems independent has no reason to discount her advice, unless someone tells them who is paying.
Bottom Line - Read the Label
On Tuesday night, MAHA’s candidates gave their concession speeches. The storefronts stayed open.
The sponsorships, salaries and advisory boards were never on the ballot, and they will outlast the movement’s moment in Washington.
MAHA promised Republicans a movement. For many of its most visible leaders, it was a revenue stream all along.
The movement tells its followers to read the label. Its leaders should put their own on the package.


